Welcome to Rustic Inn
Nestled in the heart of Oconomowoc, Rustic Inn offers a delightful dining experience marked by friendly service and a cozy atmosphere. Located at 8739 Brown St, this local gem caters to a vibrant crowd, ensuring that even on a busy night, diners enjoy swift service. Patrons rave about the flavorful Reuben, mouthwatering broasted chicken, and crispy sour cream fries, with many praising the knowledgeable and energetic staff. Whether you're watching a game or celebrating a special occasion, Rustic Inn's welcoming vibe and delicious offerings make it an ideal destination for food lovers seeking comfort and quality.
Rustic Inn: Reviews & Ratings
An all around great experience! Although the place was busy on a Friday night we got our food relatively quickly. The server was energetic and very kind! Both the Reuben and the pizza were phenomenal (great flavor and freshness).
Food was great! Bartender was wonderful! Would go back 100% They even sang happy birthday to my dad!
That was AMAZING! So I was in the mood for a burger so that's what I got and it was great. Then I tried a bite of my buddy's brosted chicken. OMG! Talk about some secret 11 herbs and spices. Delicious! Get the chicken. Put it in your mouth and be happy. Also I don't remember her name but our waitress was awesome despite being overwhelmed.
We are new to the area & found the Rustic Inn on a scenic drive to get pumpkins. We had a delicious lunch while watching football - the sour cream fries are SO good!! Our bartender took great care of us. So friendly, helpful & she seemed to know everyone. We will be back!
Met a couple of friends for dinner there on a Thursday night at about 5. It was relatively busy and they were seemingly understaffed. We sat at the bar and our bartender, Suzy, was awesome! She was friendly, efficient and she was running! I had the breasted chicken dinner, it was delicious! We will definitely be back! Thank you Suzy for the fun night, it was busy and you handled it like a CHAMP!
I had the steak sandwich with fries. My friend had the French onion soup and a Reuben and both were really good and served hot. Service was good. Atmosphere was very comfortable. Great place to spend a Saturday afternoon. It's out a ways but getting there is half the fun.
Rode the bike to breakfast and was not disappointed. Kayla was our server and she was quite possibly one of the most personable waitresses we've ever had. Food (big breakfast as well as the corned beef and hash) was excellent, came out quick and hot, and had great flavor. The garlic potatoes are a must! And the Bloody Mary? Get the one with the shrimp.... you'll thank me later.
Very friendly service and great food. Definitely try their loaded tater tots for an appetizer. I've had their boasted chicken before which was awesome. This time I tried the country fried steak which did not disappoint. Buttered green beans were also a pleasant change from what other places normally serve. Mashed potatoes were also actual mashed potatoes and not instant.
Location
-
8739 Brown St, Oconomowoc, WI 53066, United States Hotline: +1 920-474-4419
Welcome to the Rustic Inn, a delightful dining oasis nestled in the heart of Oconomowoc, WI. Located at 8739 Brown St, this welcoming establishment offers an engaging atmosphere perfect for families and friends alike. With a phone number reachable at +1 920-474-4419, Rustic Inn is not just a restaurant, but a beloved local hub where good food meets genuine camaraderie.
From the moment you step through the doors, the energy is palpable. Customers rave about the outstanding service. For instance, Malachi Dornfeld highlights the energetic and kind servers even on a busy Friday night, showing that the staff is committed to providing quick and attentive service. The quality of the food is equally impressive, with standout dishes like the phenomenal Reuben and mouthwatering pizza that promise a burst of flavor and freshness in every bite.
The menu boasts a variety of choices, appealing to all palates. Kayla H shares her delight not only in the food but also in the exceptional bartending experience, reminiscing about a heartfelt moment when the staff sang 'Happy Birthday' to her dad. This personal touch embodies the spirit of the Rustic Inn, where every visit is more than just a meal; it’s an experience to remember.
One cannot overlook the sensational broasted chicken, as noted by Matt. His euphoric exclamation about the secret blend of spices speaks volumes about the care taken in preparation. It's a dish you simply must try, as he encourages diners to "put it in your mouth and be happy." This sentiment is echoed throughout many reviews, where patrons emphasize not just the taste but the joy evoked by the food.
For those enjoying a casual lunch or catching a game, the sour cream fries have gained a reputation as a must-try, as Rebecca Young discovered on her scenic drive through the area. Her experience, paired with the friendly service from the bartender, reinforces why the Rustic Inn is quickly becoming a favorite for newcomers and locals alike.
Even in moments of busyness, like on a Thursday night, customers appreciate the dedication of the staff. Jennifer Hinrichs recounts how her waitress, Suzy, managed to make her dining experience enjoyable despite the challenges of a packed bar. The combination of attentive service and delicious meals makes every visit worth it.
The Rustic Inn truly encapsulates the essence of homely dining. Whether you’re savoring their famous broasted chicken or enjoying a slice of pizza, each dish is crafted with love and attention. Come experience the warmth, the flavor, and the joy that Rustic Inn has to offer! Your new favorite dining destination awaits.